About This Spot

Jacobs Pizza feels like the kind of neighborhood spot where familiarity meets comfort in the best way. Nestled along OH-131 in Milford, it offers a laid-back pace and an inviting atmosphere that quietly welcomes families, friends, and solo diners alike. There's a warmth that comes from the hum of casual conversations and the friendly nods exchanged over counters and tables, the kind of place where you arrive as a visitor and quickly feel like part of the local rhythm.

At Jacobs, the experience is wrapped up not just in the food itself but in those thoughtfully crafted moments around it. The balance of savory pizza sauce mingling with unexpected items like steak hoagies or crispy, crinkle-cut fries creates a sense of thoughtful playfulness. These aren't just meals but a part of an everyday celebration—a shared slice of local life where comfort edges into creativity without any fuss.

The menu speaks to those who appreciate generous portions without a hint of pretense. Whether it’s a calzone that manages to feel richly filled and satisfying or the crisp edge of fried pickles served alongside cheese bites and wings, every item lends itself to easy-going gatherings. It’s a familiar kind of joy that comes from dishes crafted with care and a nod to the flavors people remember wanting after a long day.

There’s an understated pride in being a family-run spot that stands apart from the usual bigger chains—a pride sensed in the attentive, friendly staff and the consistent quality that keeps returning guests coming back. The mood here favors comfortable, dependable dining—a place for weekend meals, quick family dinners, and those nights when you want to order something hearty and familiar without any fuss.

What’s Available Here

  • IconNo-contact delivery
  • IconDelivery
  • IconOn-site services
  • IconTakeaway
  • IconDine-in
  • IconServes local specialty
  • IconLunch
  • IconDinner
  • IconSolo dining
  • IconWheelchair-accessible car park
  • IconWheelchair-accessible entrance
  • IconWheelchair-accessible seating
  • IconWheelchair-accessible toilet
  • IconComfort food
  • IconQuick bite
  • IconSmall plates
  • IconLunch
  • IconDinner
  • IconDessert
  • IconTable service
  • IconToilet
  • IconCasual
  • IconCosy
  • IconQuiet
  • IconGroups
  • IconLocals
  • IconAccepts reservations
  • IconCredit cards
  • IconDebit cards
  • IconNFC mobile payments
  • IconCredit cards
  • IconGood for kids
  • IconKids' menu
  • IconFree of charge street parking
  • IconFree parking lot
  • IconOn-site parking
  • IconParking

Location & Hours

Monday 11:00 AM - 10:00 PM
Tuesday 11:00 AM - 10:00 PM
Wednesday 11:00 AM - 10:00 PM
Thursday 11:00 AM - 10:00 PM
Friday 11:00 AM - 10:00 PM
Saturday 11:00 AM - 10:00 PM
Sunday 11:00 AM - 10:00 PM

Guest Reviews

Kathy Perkins 08 Jan 2026

First order today. Pick 5 and the Hawaiian. Both were great. I thought the pick 5 would have the ranch on the crust in place of pizza sauce, but it was added on top. It was still good that way but a bit more of it in that application would be my preference. Recommend both. We will be back.

Kae Salyers 02 Dec 2025

Updated review: last week we decided to give Jacob's Pizza another chance, but this time we got a Pizza and a hoagie. The large pizza was very good and was enough for the 4 of us with a few pieces left over. We got a large hawaiian style pizza. As well as a steak hoagie. I really enjoyed my steak hogie.Although the bun feels like it's missing something.Maybe like a garlic powder or a garlic salt with butter on the top of the bun, kind of like Terry's does out in Lynchburg. Everything was good about the pizza as well.Everything was accurate.They have a unique tasting sauce.I'm not sure what it is about it, but it is different but good. I also appreciated being able to order online. I am raising my rating from 2 stars to 4 stars. We still would never get calzones from them again though. It would have been good if it was cooked thoroughly. We got 4 calzones. The outsides looked good but the inside was RAW. It was so doughy! They need to cook them longer on a lower temperature. Why is the outside crispy and the inside was straight up raw dough? Most of each of them went in the garbage. Terrible. Toppings were accurate and it was nice that you get marinara and garlic butter. So that's why 2 stars. At $10 a pop, and with them being so raw, it was a waste of $40. We won't ever eat here again.

Jackie Thomas 25 Oct 2025

We finally got a chance to try Jacob’s pizza last night and it was delicious! So good we actually had it again today. The pizza was delicious, fries were some of the best I’ve ever had and the calzones are fantastic. The portions are great for the price. 10/10!

Kayla Robertson 17 Oct 2025

Oh My goodness. This is absolutely my new favorite pizza place. This food is delicious and the price is amazing compared to places like LaRosa’s or Papa John’s. My favorite is the calzone. The pesto cheese bread is another great choice. Will be ordering from here now on. Happy to support a local family restaurant instead of a big chain.

DJ Day 15 Oct 2025

Got the Clazone and loved it. Unlike other pizza shops who use mostly dough with very little filling. You get the bang for your buck here at Jacob's. Sauce as a unique flavor and the staff are friendly. Has become a new rotation for quick family meals.

Mark Schuster 14 Oct 2025

A bit of a hole in the wall that doesnt look like anything to write home about. But the food is delicious. I had the cheesy garlic bread and spaghetti and meatballs. Ive been wanting to go back ever since. Long live the Italians!

Brooke Fugate 25 Sep 2025

This is by far my family’s favorite pizza place. I am a fan of thin crust and my husband is a fan of a thicker crust and this pizza is perfect for us. The sauce is great and always cheesey. Same for the calzones. Fantastic. Hoagies are just like the ones I get from a fair. We love them. Great prices too!

Kurt Hirons 23 Sep 2025

I love their gluten free pizza and their bone in wings. I asked for well done and the pizza crust is crisp! The bbq wings are FAT and juicy with plenty of sauce. Delivery was very fast! I'll be ordering from here again soon.

Share Your Experience
Related Listing

Recently Viewed Listing

4.7
935 Reviews

Tony’s Italian Restaurant

117 S Thompson St, Starke, FL 32091, United States
4.8
2079 Reviews

Presttigio Restaurante Rooftop

Cra. 10 #30-52, Tunja, Boyacá, Colombia
4.5
775 Reviews

La Banda Mexican Grill

1101 Pray Blvd, Waterville, OH 43566, United States
4.6
1809 Reviews

L'îlot Châtain

Av. Mohamed Belkhadir, Safi, Morocco
4.6
1263 Reviews

Sweetwater Chophouse

211 Carpenter Rd, Defiance, OH 43512, United States
Subscribr Now

Get All Updates & Advance Offers